Comparing Countertop Material Options

Selecting the right countertop for a bathroom or kitchen space is all about capitalizing on functionality while still allowing style to remain prominent. Whether trying to generate a warm and cozy feel or a sleek and modern spa-like oasis, selecting the perfect countertop design is key.

Countertops and Interior Design

Countertops are a perfect way to add color coordination within an interior space. Countertop color can contribute to intentional design by tying in the same hues featured elsewhere in the surrounding space, such as with lighting fixtures, bathroom handrails, or basin sinks. Another way that countertop color can be utilized is by playing in opposition to cabinets and backsplash designs to create captivating contrast.

While color is certainly an important component in interior design, material type plays a slightly larger role when it comes to countertops. Durability, scratch-resistance, water-resistance, and strength are likely to be very important if you plan on actually using the countertops for meal prep, morning routines, or even just for decor display.

There are many materials to choose from, and knowing the pros and cons of each countertop material type can help you create and execute a practical yet beautiful design with confidence. Four different materials are featured below, with one clearly coming out on top.

Butcher Block

A classic choice that complements a quaint, country-inspired aesthetic, butcher block countertops feature basic wood planks converted into smooth countertop surfaces. Different wood grains and color tones are commonly available with butcher block countertops, and this material tends to look best with clean white or cool-color palettes. By far, butcher block is one of the easiest materials to work with, which can be a great advantage for DIY designers and homeowners. It is also quite strong and can support heavy loads without breaking. The downfall to butcher block is that it can get scuffed fairly easily. In addition, it is not as water-resistant as other materials.

Laminate

Another popular choice for countertops is laminate. This material offers a wide variety of colors and patterns, so matching laminate countertops to the rest of the interior is typically not a problem. Laminate countertops are incredibly affordable, which is why they are so widely used in both residential and commercial properties. However, one of the biggest problems with laminate is the variation in quality. Some laminate options are much more durable than others, and some can be downright flimsy. Designers should really do their research before selecting a laminate countertop so they know the exact grade of product they’ll be working with. In general, it is not recommended to cut directly on laminate, as it can be easily scuffed and dented.

Premium Stone

Marble, granite, and quartz are all premium stone options that bring an elevated sophistication to interior design. While they are extremely durable and long-lasting, these materials typically require professional expertise for installation and repair, which can be inconvenient during remodeling. In addition, these materials are quite expensive.

Acrylic

Offering a beautiful balance of functionality and aesthetic appeal, acrylic countertops provide a sleek, durable surface that captures the look of luxurious stone or marble without the same price tag. Unlike laminate, acrylic countertops are durable enough to serve as a direct cutting board for meal prep. And because acrylic does not easily chip, scratch, or scuff, it’s the perfect countertop material for an active living space that sees a lot of traffic. Another huge advantage of acrylic is that it is thermoformable, meaning heat can be used during the production process to form the countertop into any unique shape you can dream up. This is ideal for seamless sinks and designers who like to create unique forms to energize the space.

Depending on your vision, you may be called to a certain material type, but if you prioritize both style and function, acrylic countertops are the way to go.

Matt Lee is the owner of the Innovative Building Materials blog and a content writer for the building materials industry. He is focused on helping fellow homeowners, contractors, and architects discover materials and methods of construction that save money, improve energy efficiency, and increase property value.